Right Reason vs Right Reasoning – Letter of Maulana Thanvi Rahmatullah Alayh
Right Reason VS. Right Reasoning
Hakim ul Ummah, Hazrat Thanwi (RA) received a letter from a person who requested some spiritual advice.
In reply to this person’s letter Hazrat Thanwi (RA) wrote, “Read twenty of my transcribed spiritual discourses and practice upon them, then inform me of your condition, i.e. whether or not you feel some spiritually elated and or change within your heart…”
After reading twenty lectures, the person replied, “Unfortunately, I have not found any change within myself at all…”
Hazrat Thanwi (RA) wrote back, “Either you have not read those lectures with the intention of spiritual rectification, or the subject-matter of those lectures you read were not spiritually-related…Or there is also a possibility that there is nothing within you which needs rectification…”
The person wrote back and admitted that he did not read the lectures with the specific intention of spiritual rectification, to which Hazrat Thanwi (RA) replied that he should do so.
The last letter of this person came saying, “Alhamdulillah, I have acquired enormous spiritual benefit from those lectures! An amazing change has now taken place from within…”
Hazrat Thanwi (RA) then comments: “Now if I would have merely prescribed some zikr or something, then he would not have benefited so greatly.
Truly, if a person does something the right way, fulfilling its rights and conditions, then Allah Ta`ala will definitely put benefit in that thing.
But our problem is that we do things according to our own understanding and deficient conjecture, due to which we end up frustrated and confused.
Today’s fake peers and money-making, Sufi shaikhs have cheated the people, taking money from them and giving them wazifas to read… Is there such a thing as becoming spiritually rectified through wazifas and awraad? Islaah and spiritual rectification can only come from spiritual rectification.”
(Malfuzaat; 8/317)
Translator’s Note: This in no way is intended to belittle the power of dua’s Azkaar, which also play an essential role in spiritual rectification. Rather this means that if a person does not make an effort on leaving sins and working on changing his evil qualities, and inculcating within himself good character, then simply reading a thousand wazifas and awraad, without a practical effort in abstaining from evil and trying to do good deeds, then these awraad alone will not rectify him.
Assabiqun – Those in Front – Hazrat Moulana Maseehullah (رحمة الله)
Extracted from “For Friends – Extracts of Maulana Maseehullah Rahmatullahi Alayhs Bayanaat”
Allah Ta’ala says in the Qur’an:
“And the foremost in the race, the foremost in the race: Those are they who will be brought nigh.”
(Surah Waqiah, Ayat 10–11)
This reminds me of the following incident which is worth pondering over.
Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) instructed a small group of four Sahabah (Radiyallahu anhu), “Depart immediately for a certain place. As far as possible, try and reach there by this time.” A time was specified.
These instructions are vital, so let me repeat them: Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) ordered four Sahabah (Radiyallahu anhu) to depart immediately for a certain place. As far as possible they had to reach there by the time specified by Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam).
It was a Friday. The time for Jumu‘ah salah came and the salah was performed by Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam). After the salah, one of the four Sahabah presented himself before Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) to make salam and musafahah (shake hands) before departing on his mission.
Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) commented, “I had instructed four of you to depart. You are alone. What happened to the other three?”
The Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) replied, “The other three had saddled their horses and had left at that time.”
“And you?”
The Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) said, “I thought to myself that today is Friday and there is great virtue in attending the Jumu‘ah salah. Because of a tremendous desire to acquire the virtues attached to this salah, I did not depart immediately. A further temptation was the blessing of performing salah behind you. The intense desire to attain these cumulative virtues made me stay behind and not depart then.”
Let us analyse his attitude. The Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) is saying that those deeds which are greater in virtue and blessings, logically, will be means of greater Qurb-e-Ilahi—i.e. the degree of qurb is proportional to the degree of virtuous deeds performed. The virtues he was counting on were that of attending the Jumu‘ah salah and being led in salah by Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam).
The Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) continued his explanation: “I have a horse that is faster than those of my companions. I will now depart and easily catch up with them along the way, and still reach our destination with them. In this way I will have attained the virtues of Jumu‘ah here, as well as carrying out your instruction to reach our destination at the time specified.”
Do you understand the points the Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) made? He wished to acquire the blessings of the Jumu‘ah salah, led by Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), as well as that of carrying out his earlier instruction.
Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) said, “Whatever you have said has its merits. However, you have not obeyed my instructions to the letter. Therefore, you have not acquired the qurb that the other three have acquired.”
The lesson is: “Was-sabiqūna as-sabiqūn, ūlā’ikal-muqarrabūn.”
Which is to say that the Qurb-e-Ilahi that the other three had attained by departing immediately—thus fulfilling the order of Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) to the letter—this Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) had not attained.
You should understand this well, and safeguard yourself from merely fulfilling your desires. Merely giving expression to one’s inner feelings is meaningless in relation to a specific instruction.
These are points to turn over in one’s mind, points to ponder over.
On the surface, what a beautiful intellectual argument, with proofs, was presented by the Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu): the virtues of Jumu‘ah, of performing salah behind Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), and, at the same time, the virtue of arriving at their destination according to Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam)’s instruction. Despite this, Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) said that he had not attained the qurb that his companions had attained by leaving immediately.
We can safely conclude: In the face of nas, there is no value to ijtihad.
In other words, in the face of explicit instructions from Allah Ta’ala or His Rasul (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), one’s own deductions and conclusions are meaningless.
This Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu) had used ijtihad (his own deductions and conclusions) in the face of nas—the specific instruction of Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) to depart immediately.
No matter how many virtues are attached to a particular action, and no matter how much qurb is attached to those virtues, these fade into insignificance in the face of obedience (ittiba‘).
To repeat: ijtihad is meaningless in the face of nas. It is apparent that ittiba‘ is basic. It is fundamental. Nothing is attained by mere expression of affection.
A further conclusion one can draw from this is: in the face of a command by one’s senior, one should not be self‐opinionated.
Of course, it goes without saying that the person who is one’s senior or elder is accepted as such and not merely recognised as such. There is a difference.
A person acting on his own deductions and conclusions is merely gratifying his own desires. He is merely satisfying his own passions. He feels his progress lies in following his own viewpoint—that his line of action is good for him. In that case how can one say he has accepted his senior as such? His verbal acknowledgement of his senior is meaningless.
Accepting someone as one’s senior and elder is to be obedient to him, provided that he is not commanding one to commit sins by disobeying Allah Ta’ala’s orders.
Therefore, in the face of a command by one’s senior, if one puts forward one’s own deductions, one will only land oneself in unnecessary problems. Then, can one expect one’s senior to come to one’s assistance?
The Sahabi (Radiyallahu anhu), on face value, had a good and perfectly logical intellectual argument. But it was contrary to Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam)’s instruction.
The final verdict of Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) was that he had not attained the taqarrub ilallah which the other three had attained, even though they were deprived of attending the Jumu‘ah salah led by Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam).
To re‐iterate: The basis of qurb is ittiba‘!
This point is emphasised time and again in the Qur’an:
“Say (O Muhammad, to mankind): If you love Allah, follow me.”
(Surah Aal-e-Imran, Ayah 31)
“Whoso obeyeth the messenger obeyeth Allah, and whoso turneth away: We have not sent thee as a warder over them.”
(Surah Nisa, Ayah 80)
“O ye who believe! Obey Allah and His messenger and turn not away from him when ye hear him (speak).”
(Surah Anfaal, Ayah 20)
The crux of the matter is: Do not intellectualise (i.e. do not put forward your own deductions and conclusions) in the face of an instruction from your senior and elder.
We had drifted to this topic when speaking of the headlong rush to sit in the majlis khana. An ayah of the Qur’an was recited earlier wherein Allah Ta’ala is instructing us about mu‘asharat.
The root of the word “mu‘asharat” is “ishrat”, which means gaiety, happy social life, pleasurable.
We are thus to spend our life in this world in aysh wa ishrat—in gaiety and happiness; in delightful ease and comfort; in peace and tranquillity with one another.
Mu‘asharat is dependent on a compatible relationship, and relationships are dependent on acceptable behaviour from all sides.
Each person should have such a relationship with the next person that there is nothing but sheer joy and comfort. There should be no displeasure. Relationships should be full of ease—not disease!
One should avoid harshness in speech and action. One’s words and the tone of one’s voice should be such as to convey ease and comfort, otherwise the desired mu‘asharat is disrupted.
ISLAAH – Moulana Maseehullah Rahmatullah Alayh’s meticulousness
Hadhratjee Rahmatullah Alayh had a place for all his belongings and everything was kept in its proper place. Even the money which he distributed to the poor and destitute was kept in neat stacks of two rupee, five rupee and ten rupee notes. His pen, ink, watch, lamp, etc. all had a special place where it was kept. If in the darkness of the night, he wanted anything, he could easily find it because everything was kept in its place.
Hadhrat Moulana Maseehullah Khan Saahib Sherwaani Rahmatullah Alayh – His life and works
ILM – Maulana Maseehullah Rahmatullah Alayh’s perfection in Ilm (knowledge)
26Hadhratjee Rahmatullah Alayh was blessed with perfection in all fields of ilm (knowledge). He was an aalim baa amal (Aalim who practiced on his knowledge). He had studied all the theological books that an aalim needed to study and gained perfection in all fields. After qualifying in Darul-Uloom Deoband, he spent another two years in Deoband and specialised in many subjects.
He began teaching the dars-e-nizaami (the aalim course syllabus) and taught all the kitaabs including Saheeh Bukhaari.
Once on a trip to France, the Arabs in the city insisted that he should deliver a talk. Many people gathered in the capital, Paris, and people from many countries were present. The host requested that Hadhratjee should speak in Urdu and he would then translate into Arabic. Hadhratjeestated: “I started the talk off by reciting the kalimah which is the branch of Imaan and also the first point of the Tableegh Jamaat. With this I started off the bayaan and, with the grace of Allah Ta‟ala, the Arabic words just began flowing from my lips. The person that had stood up to translate noticed after a while that the bayaan is in Arabic so he also sat down. I myself was surprised at how the words were just flowing from my lips. With the taufeeq of Allah I managed to deliver a lecture in Arabic for about ½ an hour to ¾ hour, whereas before this I had never delivered a talk in Arabic and had absolutely no practice. Allah Ta‟ala had blessed me with His Grace.”
Hadhratjee Rahmatullah Alayh was a personification of ilm (knowledge) and amal (practice). The barkat of practicing on one‟s knowledge was seen from the special ilm that Allah Ta‟ala bestowed on Hadhrat’s heart. Such were the pearls that would emanate from his lips that many of it would not be found in any books. This is the barkat of practicing on what one has learnt.
His specialty was the knowledge of tasawwuf. Everything that he explained in the line of islaah and tarbiyat was clearly from the teachings of the Qur-aan and the Hadith. One should refer to his book “Shariat and Tasawwuf” to get an understanding of his indepth knowledge of tasawwuf.
Another specialty of his was the manner in which he explained and simplified the teachings of Hadhrat Hakeemul-Ummat Rahmatullah Alayh. He would explain Hadhrat Thaanwi‟s majaalis in such a simple manner that the lay man would also easily understand the in-depth principles of tasawwuf.
Hadhrat Moulana Maseehullah Khan Saahib Sherwaani Rahmatullah Alayh – His life and works
Practicing on a Mustahab action brings the love of Allah – Hazrat Moulana Maseehullah Rahimahullah
Hazrat Moulana Maseehullah Rahimahullah used to say that the word “Mustahab” is derived from the root word “حُبْ”, which means love. Practicing on a Mustahab action brings the love of Allah.
Why would a person leave out a Mustahab action when he knows that it will bring him the love of Allah?
Mufti Yacoob Vally Saheb
The Qissah of the Youth who Squandered His Wealth
Let me illustrate by relating a sequence of events that Hadhratwálá Rahmatullahi Alaihi narrated to us:
There resided in Thánah Bhawan the son of a wealthy noble. His father had passed away, leaving him much wealth in the form of income producing property, farmlands and cash. A number of hangers-on surrounded him very quickly and it was not long before all his cash was spent. He then sold all his properties. When the money from the sale of these properties got finished he put up the farmlands for sale. Some well-wishers, true friends of his late father, saw the deterioration in his affairs and tried to advise him. “Arè miyán!” They tried to make him understand: “Just think how hard your father struggled to achieve some security for you, his only son. Don’t throw everything away.” The son responded by saying: “My father was a fool! He gave away silver and accumulated sand. I am not so stupid. I am more intelligent: I give away sand and acquire silver.”
In those days the rúpí coin was made of silver. There was no paper money. In buying property and farmlands (sand) the father had to pay in silver coins. The son considered himself wiser in getting silver (rúpís) for the properties and farmlands (sand) that he was selling.
Yet, the Hadith Shareef says that whosoever has property, land or farms should not sell them. The reason is obvious. These are solid and permanent investments. Cash, on the contrary, is liquid and changeable. Property will give an income. Farms will produce crops. On the other hand, cash will be spent – cash in itself is non-productive. Yes, if one wishes to buy a better property or farm, then you may sell what you have.
In this instance it is more of an exchange than a selling off. This is the extent to which Rasúlulláh Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam had concern for us, that he even advised us on worldly affairs for our material wellbeing and comfort.
The son acted contrary to the Hadíth Sharíf. Moreover, he considered himself to be clever and his father to be stupid. Can anyone make such a thick skull understand?
As an example of how his friends made use of him the following incident is related:
A friend came to visit him, looking sad and dejected. “Why so sad today?” the son asked. The friend said: “Nothing serious really. There is a fair in Mírath and I had a desire to go. Not being able to go is making me feel rotten.” The son: “Why? What is the problem?” The friend said: “To go there and also have money for the various exhibitions…” The son said: “That is no problem. Feeling better?”
The friend said: “Yes, but… To go alone without congenial company, one cannot really enjoy oneself.” The son responded: “Sure. Sure.” The son asked how much he required. The friend indicated the sum. The son very generously handed the money over. This was the manner in which he spent on his friends. The net result was that soon he had no property, no farmlands and no cash. He was reduced to begging and existed on kindly hand-outs from relatives in Hyderabad and elsewhere.
His friends? They had quietly disappeared. This is the friendship of these times.